WASHINGTON, December 9, 2009 - The importance of quality of service and the divisive effect of Net neutrality rules were key topics at the Federal Communication Commission’s Technical Advisory Process Workshop on Tuesday.
“The fundamental issue,” said Paul Sanchirico of Cisco Systems, “is ‘is my behavior affecting your experience?’ When it’s congested, I want to make sure I’m protecting everyone’s experience. There’s a greater good.”
Sanchirico suggested methods for improving network performance. Fundamental to maintaining quality of service (QoS) is establishing the prioritization of information packets.
By marking the packets and then queuing them in certain parts of the bandwidth – based upon their priority – performance can be improved, Sanchirico said. The risk associated with this method, however, is that elimination of queued packets will be concurrent across the network, and create dangerous instability.
He discussed a system, called Weighted Random Early Detection, that helps resolve this problem by dropping packets, again based upon their priority level, before destabilizing waves of network traffic appear.
WRED itself did not produce disagreement, although the principles behind it certainly did.
Other panelists were quick to question the assumptions of packet queuing, stating that weighted fair queuing assumes the existence of different levels of traffic.
Sanchirico explained the classification system used and then acknowledging the unspoken concern of privacy he added, “It’s about understanding the type, not the content of traffic.”
Professor Scott Jordan of the University of California at Irvine acknowledged packet queuing, but focused on internet architecture and how keeping traffic in certain layers can help promote competition.
Ultimately, said Jordan, the coordination of networks would be the key to maintaining QoS.
“If you go through five networks and you want a quality of service guarantee, then quality of service agreements are important,” stated Jordan. “I think enabling competition is the way to do it.”
K.C. Claffy of University of California at San Diego agreed that competition was essential, adding that, “The key is going to be transparency.”
“We’ve heard discussion about inter-domain service,” said Sanchirico acknowledging comments made by the other speakers. “Cisco’s providing the tools that can allow that to happen.”
Sanchirico’s role at Cisco forces him to deal with the practicalities of QoS. With that background, he strongly supported prioritization of packets.
- Broadband Roundup: Justice Clarence Thomas Expresses Regret on Brand X, Clearview AI Hacked, Online Privacy Act
- Registration Available for Digital Infrastructure Investment at Broadband Communities Summit on April 27, 2020
- In the Quest to Build a Better Map, Many Non-Profits and Consultants Bring Creativity and Grit to Broadband Data
- America is Either ‘In Very Good Shape’ or Has ‘Big Catch-Up’ in 5G Race with China
- Broadband Roundup: Tesla Cars Ain’t Driverless, Suspicious Bernie Sanders Facebook Posts, ReConnect Awards
Signup for Broadband Breakfast
Digital Inclusion3 weeks ago
New Technology of Augmented Reality, Including Eye Control, Enable Greater Access By Disability Community
Broadband's Impact1 month ago
Todd Foje: Can High-Speed Broadband Finally Bridge the Gap Between Rural and Urban Communities?
Broadband Data4 weeks ago
Despite Promising Gains in Connectivity, Report from Broadband Now Highlights the Extent of the Digital Divide
5G1 month ago
Gordon Smith: Can a 5G Fund Connect Rural America at 21st Century Speeds?
Expert Opinion3 weeks ago
An Open Letter to Gwynne Shotwell, Elon Musk and Starlink Leadership: Three Reasons to Make Starlink Open Access for America’s Local ISPs
Broadband's Impact4 weeks ago
Rural Healthcare Providers Could Be Surprised by FCC’s Recent Changes to Rural Healthcare Program
Expert Opinion3 weeks ago
Jeff Grappone: State of the Union Address Is No Longer the Political Equivalent of the Super Bowl
China1 week ago
Tech Officials Diagnose Excessive Trump Actions as Product of ‘Huawei Derangement Syndrome’