WASHINGTON, July 25, 2019 — The efficacy of antitrust enforcement against big tech companies was energetically debated at an Internet Governance Forum conference on Thursday.
The current consumer welfare standard sufficiently supports robust antitrust merger analysis, claimed Keith Klovers, an attorney advisor at the Federal Trade Commission. Although each new market and investigation has its own unique facts, the same law can still apply.
The Department of Justice and FTC are enforcement agencies, which limits their power to take action, said Public Knowledge President Chris Lewis. This creates a need for going beyond the limits of antitrust to protect the marketplace.
Another barrier to enforcement is the difficulty of discerning between efficiency-enhancing acquisitions and problematic acquisitions, said Orrick Partner Alex Okuliar.
We need some sort of nondiscrimination rule to promote competition, localism, and small independent voices in the marketplace, said Lewis, highlighting the need for a new metric to determine when a platform is dominant.
Current laws are very capable of addressing the issues at hand, argued Jeff Farrah, general counsel for the National Venture Capital Association. If the dominant operator is using its position to discriminate against companies that operate on the platform, that exclusionary content could be addressed under the existing law.
While the standard of “consumer welfare” could be more clearly defined, it’s a good standard, Farrah said, suggesting that antitrust laws should slowly evolve to reflect the market rather than being dramatically changed.
Replacing antitrust standards with prescriptive regulation would “effectively calcify the existing market dynamics,” cautioned Okuliar.
Things have changed since the days of Standard Oil, Lewis said. New mergers such as Facebook and WhatsApp are far less disruptive to the marketplace, due to the constant trend of rapidly changing technology.
The goal should not be to completely replace antitrust laws, Lewis said, but to implement “an appropriate complement based on analysis” that factors in technological developments like the rise of big data the Internet of Things.
Policymakers should consider using a cost of exclusion metric to measure the impact of network effects on digital platforms, Lewis continued. At some point, big social media platforms such as Facebook become so ubiquitous that there is a cost to individuals or businesses to not be on the network, potentially having a prohibitive effect on competition.
The discussion followed a tumultuous week for big tech, as Facebook disclosed on Wednesday that the Federal Trade Commission had opened an antitrust investigation into the company.
Antitrust action is also being considered against other tech giants such as Amazon, which Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin said on Wednesday has “destroyed the retail industry across the United States.”
(Picture of panel by Emily McPhie.)
- Part III: The GOP Wants to Kill the Fairness Doctrine, Then Applies It to the Internet
- Justice Department Collaborating with State Attorneys General’s Antitrust Investigation of Big Tech, Says Chief
- Part II: Senators Josh Hawley and Ted Cruz Want to Repeal Section 230 and Break the Internet
- A Short History of Online Free Speech, Part I: The Communications Decency Act Is Born
- Free Press Denounces Facebook Ads, New Content Moderation, Problems of Broadband Adoption
Intellectual Property3 weeks ago
In Congressional Oversight Hearing, Register of Copyrights Says Office Is Responding to Online Users
Broadband Data3 months ago
Pennsylvania Broadband Speeds Worse Than Previously Believed, According to State Report
Fiber2 weeks ago
‘Dig Once’ Provides Future-Proofing Solution for Federal Highway Infrastructure, Says BroadbandNow
Broadband Data2 months ago
California Report: Income Most Significant Factor in Low Broadband Adoption
Drones2 weeks ago
Greater Commercial Use of Drones Will Force Revisions of Federal Aviation Administration Regulations, Say Experts
Broadband Roundup1 week ago
Trump Delays 10 Percent Tariff on Chinese Tech Goods, Buttigieg on Broadband, Facebook Eavesdropping
Broadband Roundup1 week ago
Cable Industry Touts Energy Efficiency, Next Century Highlights Open Access Fiber, Aspen Forum Set
Broadband Roundup2 weeks ago
Rep. Bob Latta and Ajit Pai on Robocalls, Rural Massachusetts Projects, John Horrigan Report on Digital Divide