WASHINGTON, March 23, 2020 – “Democracies will be at a disadvantage” if deepfakes become common, Emerging Technologies Fellow Lindsay Gorman told panelists gathered online, on March 12 at the Information Technology Innovation Foundation.
Surprisingly, while deepfakes present an extraordinary, fast-moving challenge, deepfakes can be used for good as well.
Gorman argued that because democracies rely on facts and trust in government figures who can communicate directly with the people, deepfakes can erode this system.
Deepfakes are altered “synthetic media” that can take several forms: fake videos, images, comments, texts, audio, etc.
Gorman said there has been an “explosion of cheapfakes” in the political realm. When there is a “technical manipulation” it would be helpful to clearly label it rather than take it down and enter into the discourse of constitutional rights, said Gorman.
Pornographic videos are the most common deepfakes, but the conversation seems to swirl around misinformation, said ITIF Vice President Daniel Castro.
Several universities are working to “help communities in detection” because these technologies are varied and diverse, said Facebook Cybersecurity Policy Lead Saleela Salahuddin. “The speed of detection is critical,” said Salahuddin.
Salahuddin said users have to be cautious because the “adversary will pivot to find some loophole” in your protections and detection.
The audio aspect creates a great threat because the technology can learn the speaker’s voice and regurgitate scripted lines, said Ben Sheffner, vice president and associate general counsel for Motion Picture Association.
Salahuddin said a financial institution Facebook works with was concerned about what deepfake audio could mean for accessing financial information and accounts. Salahuddin suggested that while deepfakes are spreading wildly, this speed could be a catalyst for “growth and resilience.”
“Detection is crucial,” said Gorman. But regarding misinformation, instead of solely being distrustful of everything users see, there is a need to find factual and trustworthy sources of information, Gorman said.
Not trusting anything is an “authoritarian model,” warned Gorman.
Congressional fever to legislate regarding deepfakes can be “tempered” by recognizing that there are laws that already protect users from a lot of the harms that are inflicted by deepfakes, said Sheffner.
But the first amendment makes it challenging to regulate even “false speech,” Sheffner said.
Michael Clauser, head of data and trust at Access Partnership, doesn’t think deepfakes are all bad—a position he came to over time. While working with a technologist, Clauser learned that the “underlying technology” of deepfakes can be used to solve issues by orchestrating and training algorithms when they are missing data.
For example, deepfakes can train artificial intelligence to recognize cancer in diagnostic tests.
Clauser said “draconian laws” for deepfakes would actually be more damaging for the United States than helpful.
- Coronavirus Roundup: Speedy FCC Web Meeting, NCTA Broadband Dashboard, GEO’s New Mapping Tool
- Although Privacy is on a Back Burner, California May Outdo Its Own State Law in November
- Speaking to Utah Entrepreneurs, Sen. Romney Emphasizes Communication and Says, ‘We Have to Stop Looking Like Italy’
- Coronavirus Roundup: Fighting Against the Homework Gap, No Fixed Data Caps in U.K., Gigabit Libraries on Role in Pandemic
- FCC Praises $200 Million for Telemedicine, Outlines Process for Up To $1 Million in Aid Per Applicant
Signup for Broadband Breakfast
China1 month ago
Tech Officials Diagnose Excessive Trump Actions as Product of ‘Huawei Derangement Syndrome’
Health4 weeks ago
Battling Coronavirus COVID-19, Broadband Could Provide Relief Although Telemedicine May Not Help
Section 2301 month ago
Attorney General Bill Barr Calls for ‘Recalibrated’ Section 230 as Justice Department Hosts Tech Immunity Workshop
Health2 weeks ago
Broadband Breakfast Live Online Will Stream Daily in March on ‘Broadband and the Coronavirus’
Net Neutrality1 month ago
FCC Seeks Comment on Net Neutrality Issues Remanded by Appeals Court: Public Safety, Pole Attachments and Lifeline
Artificial Intelligence1 month ago
U.S. Progress on AI and Quantum Computing Will Best China, Says CTO Michael Kratsios
Broadband Mapping & Data1 month ago
Poor Broadband Maps and Lack of a Consolidated Voice Hinder Advocacy for Better Rural Internet
Asia1 month ago
Broadband Roundup: Global Internet Censorship, Tribal Divide, Klobuchar on the Broadband Stump