Broadband Roundup
NY Sued Over Low-Cost Internet, Apple Antitrust Allegations, CETF Concludes Surveys, 5G Device Growth
New York sued over $15 internet, Apple faces EU antitrust allegations, California surveys conclude, and 5G device adoption grows.

May 4, 2021—Trade groups representing telecom companies including AT&T and Verizon are suing New York for creating a low-cost broadband tier they alleged it doesn’t have the right to arbitrarily set.
The bill, which was signed by Governor Andrew Cuomo last month, was designed to create an affordable tier of broadband service that does not exceed $15 per month. The average price for broadband in New York is $50 per month.
Ten separate organizations are listed as the plaintiffs in the lawsuit, including the New York State Telecommunications Association, Cellular Telecommunications Industry Association (CTIA), and the NTCA.
The suit alleges the state should not have the right to legislate what prices they can set for consumers, particularly considering that many of the telecom companies represented by the plaintiffs already provide affordable tiers to underserved and economically disadvantaged communities.
The state estimated that as many as seven million people across nearly three million households would qualify for this tier of broadband.
“This is nothing more than a transparent attempt by billion-dollar corporations putting profit ahead of creating a more fair and just society,” Cuomo said in response to the lawsuit, “Let me be abundantly clear — providing internet in the Empire State is not a god given right. If these companies want to pick this fight, impede the ability of millions of New Yorkers to access this essential service and prevent them from participating in our economic recovery, I say bring it on.”
Apple faces antitrust violations in EU
Competition Commissioner of the European Commission Margrethe Vestager announced last month that Apple was allegedly engaging in anticompetitive activities by requiring music-streaming apps on iPhones to process their in-app purchases through Apple’s payment system, allowing the tech giant to skim money off the top.
“An app store can become a gatekeeper,” Vestager said during her announcement of the charges, “in particular if there is only one app store available in a mobile ecosystem.” Notably, Apple does not offer an alternative method to download software.
Apple takes a 30 percent fee on every transaction that is processed through its system.
On Monday, Apple had its first day in court against Epic Games, whose popular game Fortnite was the subject of a related controversy when its makers allowed players to circumvent Apple’s fees by creating an in-game system for in-game purchases. Apple responded by banning the game app from its store and accused Epic of violating its terms of service.
CETF-USC concludes Statewide Broadband Adoption survey
The California Emerging Technology Fund conducted a series of surveys in conjunction with the University of Southern California regarding broadband use during the pandemic.
There were notable disparities along income levels, as lower-income families reported lower levels of technology adoption, despite improvement over the course of the pandemic. Additionally, the Fund also noted that children in immigrant communities are taking longer to return to school, with only 42 percent of parents in LA Unified School District (featuring a sizeable immigrant population) stating that they have plans to send their children back to school, compared to 82 percent of parents in West LA (with a smaller immigrant population).
According to the study, access to connected devices is growing, but racial minorities are still disproportionately impacted by the digital divide. This issue is compounded low awareness of programs designed to help consumers secure affordable internet. Data collected reflected that only a third of surveyed parents were aware of such programs.
The study also said 84 percent of surveyed adults were sufficiently connected, 5.6 percent were under-connected with only a smartphone to access the internet, and 9.6 were not connected to the internet.
More than half of all smartphones sold since Q4 2020 are 5G capable
According to data published by Counterpoint, more than 53 million smart devices equipped with 5G were sold between the launch of 5G in 2019 and the end of the first quarter of 2021, by which point it amounted to 57 percent of all smart devices sold.
This milestone is in no small part thanks to the release of Apple’s iPhone 12.
Jeff Fieldhack, who is strategies director for the US Mobile Devices and Carrier, said he anticipates that as 5G continues to become more widespread, new technologies improve, and sales continue to increase, the price of the technology will drop.
“We believe 5G prices will drop below $250 in H2 2021. Qualcomm’s 400 series Snapdragon processor and MediaTek’s 700 and 800 Dimensity series chips will help achieve these price drops.”
Broadband Roundup
Google AI and Mayo Clinic, Spectrum Ohio Expansion, New CFO for Gigstreem
The partnership will allow healthcare professionals to analyze patient data and medical history.

June 7, 2023 – Google announced on Wednesday a partnership with non-profit medical center the Mayo Clinic for the use of generative artificial intelligence to process data.
The partnership will allow healthcare professionals to analyze patient data, including medical history, imaging records, genomics, or lab results, more efficiently and with a single query. The AI is able to access information that is stored in diverse formats and locations.
Generative AI is a type of artificial intelligence that can generate new content, such as images, text, or even music, without being explicitly programmed to do so. It uses complex algorithms and patterns learned from large datasets to create original and creative outputs.
Google announced this on the back of releasing its trial AI chatbot, called Bard.
Issues with generative AI models have revolved around the datasets used to train them. While the models reflect inaccuracies, biases or other harmful content, imposing intense regulations on datasets leads to decreased performance.
Spectrum plowing $18M in Ohio broadband expansion
Internet service provider Spectrum said Tuesday it is investing $18 million for the expansion of high-speed internet in Clinton County, Ohio.
The money will go toward connecting over 5,000 homes and small businesses across all 13 townships in the country.
“I am pleased that the Rural Digital Opportunity Fund and Spectrum were able to help with the needed expansion of rural broadband in Southwestern Ohio, helping to connect over 5,000 small businesses and homes,” U.S. Rep. Brad Wenstrup, R-Ohio, said in a press release. “Our students, seniors, and businesses rely on the power of fast and affordable internet for education, connection, and growth. This expansion will help grow the capabilities of our communities.”
Spectrum is a group of communications services offered by Charter Communications, Inc., whose services include internet, mobile, television and voice services.
Virginia-based Gigstreem announces new CFO
Internet service provider Gigstreem announced Tuesday the appointment of Patrick Albus as its chief financial officer.
Gigstreem’s CEO, Andrew Kusminsky, said in a press release he expects Albus’s strategic planning and operational focus to contribute to the company’s long-term success.
Albus arrives at the job with over two decades of leadership experience and financial expertise, the company said. He joined the company in December 2022, and supported funding efforts and expansion through acquisitions.
Established in 2017, Gigstreem is a provider catering to apartment buildings, residential communities, businesses, and events across the nation.
Gigstreem recently secured $59 million in funding and completed three acquisitions, with more planned, it said.
Broadband Roundup
Charter Chooses Nokia for 5G, Microsoft Children’s Privacy Settlement, FCC Adopts $5M Robocall Fine
Charter has selected Nokia for its 5G rollout.

June 6, 2023 — Charter Communications will use Nokia’s equipment to support the company’s 5G network rollout, according to a press release Monday.
Charter will deploy a wide range of assets in the Finnish company’s 5G radio access network technology, read the release.
The deal will help Charter continue to deliver high-speed 5G connection across its 41 targeted states, the company said.
“Incorporating Nokia’s innovative 5G technology into our advanced wireless converged network will help us ensure that Spectrum customers in areas with a high concentration of mobile traffic continue to receive superior mobile connectivity, including the nation’s fastest wireless speeds,” Justin Colwell, executive vice president of connectivity technology at Charter, said in the release.
After investing $464.25 million in 2020 to acquire 210 spectrum licenses, this is the next phase of Charter’s aim to build its mobile network business, the company said.
The company also said it sees growth in its broadband portfolio with a $60 million funding through Florida’s broadband program.
Microsoft settles on $20M for children’s privacy violations
Microsoft has agreed to pay $20 million after it violated provisions of the Children’s Online Privacy Protection law, the Federal Trade Commission announced Monday.
The FTC voted 3-0 to hand the settlement to the Department of Justice, which on the same day filed the complaint in federal court for it to take effect.
The FTC alleges the corporation had broken three major provisions of the children’s privacy law, specifically, that it failed to provide parents appropriate warning before collecting children’s personal information via the Xbox gaming platform. The company also withheld and shared the data with third parties without permission, the complaint says.
As part of the settlement, the company must also adopt new policies to strengthen privacy safeguards for Xbox players under the age of 13.
“Our proposed order makes it easier for parents to protect their children’s privacy on Xbox, and limits what information Microsoft can collect and retain about kids,” Samuel Levine, director of the FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection, said in a press release. “This action should also make it abundantly clear that kids’ avatars, biometric data, and health information are not exempt from COPPA.”
Dave McCarthy, corporate vice president of Xbox Player Services, confirmed Microsoft had agreed to FTC’s settlement in an announcement the same day.
“Regrettably, we did not meet customer expectations and are committed to complying with the order to continue improving upon our safety measures,” McCarthy said. “We believe that we can and should do more, and we’ll remain steadfast in our commitment to safety, privacy, and security for our community.”
The technology sector has recently been under scrutiny for its allegedly lax approach to protecting the online privacy of children. Earlier in May, the FTC accused Facebook of breaking a privacy rule pertaining to minors. Concerns for the physical and mental health of juvenile users have also prompted lawmakers to lead the charge against Chinese-owned video-sharing app TikTok.
FCC adopts $5 million penalty in robocall scheme
The Federal Communications Commission on Tuesday issued a $5-million fine against entities involved an illegal robocall scheme during the 2020 election.
John M. Burkman, Jacob Alexander Wohl, and J.M. Burkman & Associates LLC sent out 1,141 robocalls to potential voters warning against mail-in voting as their “personal information will be part of a public database that will be used by police departments to track down old warrants and be used by credit card companies to collect outstanding debts.”
The robocalls were delivered without the consent of the receivers, which violated the FCC’s rules.
“This penalty emphasizes the seriousness with which we take our obligations to protect American consumers, and in this instance American voters, from being targeted through the clear and illegal misuse of U.S. communications networks,” said FCC Enforcement Chief Loyaan Egal.
In response to the 2021’s FCC fine proposal, Wohl and Burkman argued that political robocalls are exempt from the Telephone Consumer Protection Act restrictions, which require telemarketers to ask for consents before robocalling consumers.
The FCC denied this claim, saying that “a calling campaign is political in nature does not protect the caller from liability under Commission rules.”
Broadband Roundup
AI Regulation Bill, Quantum Fiber in More Cities, Charter Awarded $60M in Florida Broadband
The AI Disclosure Act would require disclosures on all AI-generated content.

Representative Ritchie Torres, D-N.Y. will introduce a bill this week that would require any content generated by artificial intelligence to include a disclaimer noting the source of the content.
The AI Disclosure Act of 2023 would require that any AI-generated content include the statement, “Disclaimer: this output has been generated by artificial intelligence.” The Federal Trade Commission would be responsible for implementation and enforcement of the law.
“AI is the most revolutionary technology of our time. It has the potential to be a weapon of mass disinformation, dislocation, and destruction,” Torres said in a statement. Regulation of the technology will be “one of the central challenges confronting Congress in the years and decades to come.”
According to Torres, the disclosure is “the simplest place to start” AI regulation. “Disclosure is by no means a magic bullet but it’s a common-sense starting point to what will surely be a long road to regulation,” Torres said.
A group of AI experts issued a statement in May claiming that “mitigating the risk of extinction from AI should be a global priority alongside other societal-scale risks such as pandemics and nuclear war.”
The warning comes as Congress focuses its attention on AI regulation, as a proliferation of increasingly sophisticated AI chatbots emerge in the market.
Quantum Fiber in 18 more cities
Quantum Fiber, a Lumen Technologies brand, announced Monday its gigabit internet speeds are now available in 18 additional cities across the country.
The additional cities are: Boise in Idaho; Cape Coral, Fort Myers, Naples and Orlando in Florida; Colorado Springs and Denver in Colorado; Des Moines in Iowa; Las Vegas in Nevada; Minneapolis in Minnesota; Omaha in Nebraska; Phoenix and Tucson in Arizona; Portland in Oregon; Salt Lake City in Utah; and Seattle, Spokane and Vancouver in Washington.
“With each new city, thousands more people gain access to our reliable internet. It’s an investment with rippling benefits for not only families and businesses, but also our larger work to support digital inclusion,” Maxine Moreau, Lumen president of mass markets, said in a press release.
The company is set to connect more than 500,000 homes and small businesses this year, it said. “We’re excited to expand our fiber footprint with gig and multi-gig internet into these markets,” said Moreau.
Charter awarded $60M in Florida broadband funding program
Florida announced Friday that Charter Communications will receive approximately $14.3 million for eight projects across the state as part of the Broadband Opportunity Program.
The 22 announced awards this round make up $60 million in broadband investments. Providers are required to deploy fiber broadband with 1 Gbps symmetrical download and upload speeds.
More than $226 million has been awarded through Florida’s Broadband Opportunity Program, which will connect more than 250,000 addresses in the state. The state allocated $400 million of the funds to increase reliable broadband service within the state in a competitive reimbursement grant program.
The state was awarded nearly $9 billion through the State and Local Fiscal Recovery Program under the American Rescue Plan Act, which delivered $350 billion to states to support the response to the COVID-19 global pandemic.
-
Open Access4 weeks ago
AT&T Closes Open Access Fiber Deal With BlackRock
-
Expert Opinion3 weeks ago
Scott Wallsten: A $10 Billion Broadband Black Hole?
-
Digital Inclusion4 weeks ago
Debra Berlyn: Creating a Path to Close the Digital Divide for Older Adults
-
5G4 weeks ago
Crown Castle CEO Says 5G Plus Fixed Wireless Can Rival Fiber Connections
-
NTIA3 weeks ago
NTIA Should Remove Letter of Credit Requirement in BEAD Program, Event Hears
-
Broadband Roundup2 weeks ago
‘Urgent’ Social Media Advisory, Tribal Broadband Awards, Permitting Reform Progress, BroadbandNow Podcast
-
Artificial Intelligence3 weeks ago
Senate Witnesses Call For AI Transparency
-
#broadbandlive3 weeks ago
Broadband Breakfast on May 31, 2023 – Tribal Broadband Deployment