Former Officials: FCC’s Independence ‘Obliterated’ Under Carr
The FCC now serves political interests instead of the public, former agency officials said.
The FCC now serves political interests instead of the public, former agency officials said.
WASHINGTON, Nov. 12, 2025 – Former regulators and policy advocates accused Federal Communications Commission Chairman Brendan Carr of having “obliterated” the FCC’s credibility as an independent, expert regulatory body.
Speaking at the People’s Oversight Hearing convened Wednesday by digital rights group Public Knowledge, experts examined whether the FCC could still serve the public interest or whether, as some argued, it had become too politically captured to function as an independent regulator.
Former FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler, who led the agency under President Obama, said the the FCC’s statutory independence had collapsed under Carr. “The FCC was designed to exist as an amphibian between the administration and Congress,” he said. “But when an authoritarian president steps in and overturns that balance, there are consequences.”
State regulators would require ISPs to provide safe, adequate, and reliable service to customers under just, fair, and reasonable terms and conditions.
Providers cited payment instability and post-construction costs, while officials urged an Affordability Connectivity Program replacement.
From company's HQ, Tarana Wireless CEO Basil Alwan cited higher network capacity even under heavy interference
A panel of policy experts said there could be movement on areas of bipartisan consensus
Member discussion